Birthright citizenship has been a cornerstone of American law since the 14th Amendment to the Constitution was ratified in 1868. Recently, discussions have surfaced questioning whether a future administration, particularly under Donald Trump, could remove this fundamental right. Here's what you need to know.
What Is Birthright Citizenship?
Birthright citizenship grants U.S. citizenship to any person born on U.S. soil, regardless of the immigration status of their parents. This right stems from the Citizenship Clause of the 14th Amendment, which explicitly states:
"All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside."
This clause was a direct response to the infamous Dred Scott decision, a Supreme Court ruling that denied citizenship to Black Americans. By enshrining birthright citizenship in the Constitution, the 14th Amendment sought to ensure equality and undo the damages of slavery and systemic racial discrimination.
Why Is This Important?
Birthright citizenship is not just a legal technicality; it is a fundamental principle of inclusion. Historically, stripping individuals of citizenship has led to catastrophic consequences. For example, Nazi Germany's Nuremberg Laws revoked the citizenship of Jewish people, setting the stage for the Holocaust.
This dark history serves as a cautionary tale, highlighting the risks of undermining citizenship rights and the importance of vigilance when such discussions arise.
Can Trump Actually Take It Away?
The short answer: It’s nearly impossible.
To amend the Constitution, a president would need:
A two-thirds majority in both the House of Representatives and the Senate.
Ratification by three-fourths of the states (38 out of 50).
This process is intentionally arduous, making constitutional amendments exceedingly rare. Currently, the political landscape lacks the overwhelming support needed to repeal or alter birthright citizenship.
While executive orders or legislation could attempt to circumvent this constitutional guarantee, such actions would undoubtedly face immediate legal challenges and likely fail in the courts.
Why Raise the Issue at All?
The suggestion to revoke birthright citizenship, even if unfeasible, reflects a broader political strategy. It perpetuates misconceptions about immigration, such as the false narrative that having a child in the U.S. automatically “fixes” a parent’s immigration status.
In reality, this process is anything but straightforward. U.S.-born children cannot petition for their parents’ legal status until they turn 21. Even then, parents must meet stringent eligibility criteria, such as lawful entry into the U.S. or specific waivers for unlawful presence.
The Real Challenge for Immigrant Families
Many immigrant parents wait decades, raising U.S.-citizen children, only to discover they remain ineligible for legal status. This heartbreaking reality underscores the need for comprehensive immigration reform.
Our laws fail to account for the sacrifices these families make and the contributions they bring to the U.S. Revoking birthright citizenship wouldn’t simplify immigration—it would further complicate an already broken system.
The Bigger Picture
While the likelihood of repealing birthright citizenship is slim, the broader implications of such discussions are troubling. Even raising the idea creates fear and uncertainty within immigrant communities and stokes division in the broader population.
Moreover, the focus on birthright citizenship distracts from more pressing issues, such as the need for policies that support families, streamline immigration processes, and ensure fair treatment for all individuals within the U.S.
A Message for Immigrants
At Landerholm Immigration, we understand the challenges immigrants face. Despite political rhetoric and policy changes, we remain committed to fighting for your American dream. If you have questions about your immigration status or your rights, we’re here to help.
The journey may not be easy, but with the right legal strategy and support, it’s possible to overcome even the most daunting obstacles.
If you found this article helpful, consider subscribing to our YouTube channel for more updates and insights on immigration law. Together, we can navigate these complex issues and build a brighter future.
Remember: Knowledge is power. Let’s empower immigrants to thrive, no matter the challenges ahead.